NFL MVP Win Count Comparison (AP Awards)
Who owns the most NFL MVP Awards ever recorded in total? Compare 12 AP career totals, from 2 Mahomes magic youth to 5 Manning sheriff record reign vote.
Visual comparison
All values
Click any row to load it as Entry A.
| Name | Value | Context | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peyton Manning Only 5 time winner. | 5 titles | 2003 to 2013 Colts Broncos | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Manning 5 |
| Aaron Rodgers Back to back twice. | 4 titles | 2011 to 2021 Packers | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Rodgers 4 |
| Tom Brady Unanimous 2010. | 3 titles | 2007 2010 2017 Patriots | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Brady 3 |
| Brett Favre Only 3 straight. | 3 titles | 1995 to 1997 straight | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Favre 3 straight |
| Jim Brown Rookie plus two. | 3 titles | 1957 1958 1965 Browns | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Brown 3 |
| Johnny Unitas Baltimore era. | 3 titles | 1959 1964 1967 Colts | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Unitas 3 |
| Otto Graham AAFC plus NFL. | 3 titles | 1951 1953 1955 Browns | Wikipedia MVP table: Graham 3 |
| Joe Montana Back to back. | 2 titles | 1989 1990 49ers | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Montana 2 |
| Steve Young Lefty efficiency. | 2 titles | 1992 1994 49ers | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Young 2 |
| Kurt Warner Grocery to MVP. | 2 titles | 1999 2001 Rams | Wikipedia MVP table: Warner 2 |
| YA Tittle Back to back old era. | 2 titles | 1962 1963 Giants | Wikipedia MVP table: Tittle 2 |
| Patrick Mahomes Active chase. | 2 titles | 2018 2022 Chiefs | Wikipedia AP MVP list: Mahomes 2 |
About this converter
AP NFL MVP counts run from two timers to Manning alone at five. Montana, Young, Warner, Tittle and Mahomes open at 2 each across eras. Brady, Favre, Brown, Unitas and Graham share 3 each with Favre the only three straight from 1995 to 1997 in Green Bay. Rodgers at 4 won back to back twice in Green Bay. Manning at 5 from 2003 to 2013 with two teams stands alone with a unanimous 2013 season of 55 touchdowns. Counts follow the Wikipedia AP MVP tables with NFL.com cross-checks. Pre 1961 Outstanding Player nods sit inside some old totals and are labeled by the league.
How to use it
Pick two players and a unit in the top row. The three boxes below stay linked. Change any box and the other two update. One box holds a count of the first player, one holds the matching count of the second, one holds the titles in the chosen unit. Try 1 Manning against Montanas to compare record against two timer.
Counts are AP MVP awards since 1957. Shared 2003 Manning McNair year counts once each. Postseason play stays out of voting.
FAQ
Who has most NFL MVPs?
Manning with 5 from 2003 to 2013.
Who won 3 straight?
Favre 1995 to 1997, the only one.
How many does Brady have?
3 in 2007 2010 and 2017.
Does Mahomes have 2?
Yes, 2018 and 2022.
Sources
- Wikipedia AP NFL MVP tables (Manning 5, Rodgers 4, Brady Favre Brown Unitas 3)
- NFL.com Manning fifth MVP report (2013 unanimous near vote, 55 TD season)
- Wikipedia MVP awards list (Montana Young Warner Tittle Mahomes 2 each)
Last verified: 2026-10-05 · 12 entries
More arcade scores converters
100m Sprint Record Comparison (Seconds)
Compare 10 fastest legal 100 meter sprint times in seconds, from Bolt at 9.58 to Greene at 9.79. World Athletics marks in a linked tool here. right now.
100m World Record Progression Comparison (Men)
Compare 15 mens 100m world records, from Lippincott 10.6 to Bolt 9.58. World Athletics progression data in a linked tool. See bars. Verified now. Verified.
12 Monkeys Episode Count Comparison (Seasons)
How many 12 Monkeys episodes per season? Compare all 4 season counts plus the 47 total, from 10 in season 3 to 13 in early years, using Syfy guides. Data.
← NFL All-Time Interception Comparison (Career INTs) · NFL Career Passing Yard Total Comparison (All-Time) →